Our Desserts


Bakester Boards

Craving a wide variety of unique, and tasty treats? Our Bakester Boards offer the ideal solution, presenting a diverse assortment of sweets for your guests to indulge in and enjoy.

Fluffernutter Cookies

Our signature cookie combines the delicious flavors of peanut butter and marshmallow! These scrumptious sandwich cookies are comprised of two soft peanut butter cookies with homemade vanilla bean marshmallow fluff sandwiched in between. Tastes like heaven!

Fluff Tarts

You won’t find anything like our fluff tarts anywhere else! These layered desserts consist of a crumbly crust, a delicious ganache, and homemade marshmallow fluff. Savor these in a variety of flavors, including S’mores, Pretzel & Peanut Butter, Cookie Butter, a...

Marshmallow Pops

The most fun way to indulge in our marshmallows! These delightful treats feature our homemade marshmallow, dipped in luscious Belgian chocolate or candy coating, and adorned with festive decorations. Perfect for gifts and party favors, they are a sweet surprise that will bring...

Irish Stout Brownies

These yummy brownies are a customer favorite for a reason! They are rich and gooey on the inside and topped with a delicious Irish stout buttercream. The secret ingredient is Guinness Irish Stout. Shh... don't tell anyone!

Funfetti Fluff Dippers

Like dunkaroos for a new generation! These sprinkle-filled buttery sugar cookies are paired with our homemade vanilla bean marshmallow fluff! The cookies are delicious on their own, but the fluff takes them to the next level!

Hot Cocoa Bombs

Are you ready for the perfect cup of hot cocoa? Our hot cocoa bombs are made with a rich, Belgian milk chocolate shell filled with tasty hot cocoa mix and our gourmet marshmallows. They make great gifts!

Gourmet Marshmallows

Our made-from-scratch marshmallows are like nothing you’ve ever tasted before! You can enjoy them in hot beverages, s’mores, as a garnish for desserts, or as a simple snack. They come in a variety of unique flavors, such as Cake Batter, Cookies and Cream, Toasted C...

Brownie Pops

Our brownie pops are cherished by chocolate lovers! Crafted from our indulgent Irish Stout Brownies infused with the richness of Guinness, our treats are transformed into delightful bites. Each is dipped in velvety Belgian chocolate and decorated to match your event theme.
Cake Pops Pink Blue Baby Shower

Cake Pops

You’ll be able to tell from the first bite that we don’t take any shortcuts when we craft our cake pops. We start by baking a fresh, mouthwatering cake from scratch and then whip up a rich and creamy buttercream to blend with the cake. A quick dip in candy coating ...

Handcrafted Pies

Savor the rich tradition of our handcrafted pies, a cherished family pastime Becky inherited from her grandma and great-grandma. From beloved classics like Apple and Pumpkin to innovative flavors like Snickerdoodle and S’mores, our pie offerings ensure a delightful treat...

Marshmallow Bonbons

Get ready for the ultimate indulgence with our marshmallow bonbons – the epitome of decadence! Beginning with a luscious Belgian chocolate shell, we generously fill these treats with our irresistibly fluffy homemade marshmallow. We go the extra mile to elevate our larger...


Contact Us Now


We’re not your average bakery – and we’re proud of it! While many bakeries stick to the familiar, we take immense pride in crafting unique treats and desserts that set us apart from the rest. Located in Westfield, Becky the Bakester provides custom desserts for event catering throughout Central Indiana, including Indianapolis, Carmel, Noblesville, Fishers, Zionsville, and surrounding areas.


Contact Us

203 Jersey St.

Westfield, Indiana 46074


Tuesdays - Fridays: 10 am - 6 pm
Saturdays: 10 am - 2 pm

Get all the Sweet Details

Sign up for our VIP Email List to be notified of all the newest sweets and treats, holiday sales, and upcoming events! Provide your birthday to get a gift to celebrate your special day!